April 25 is almost here…#lestweforget

CONTRO OGNI RITORNO                              

Piero Calamandrei    

Inermi borgate dell’alpe
asilo di rifugiati
prese d’assalto coi lanciafiamme
arsi vivi nel rogo dei casali
i bambini avvinghiati alle madri
fosse notturne scavate
dagli assassini in fuga
per nascondervi stragi di trucidati innocenti
questo vi riuscì.
S. Terenzio Bergiola Zeri Vinca
Forno Mommio Traverde S. Anna S. Leonardo
scrivete questi nomi
son le vostre vittorie
ma espugnare queste trincee di marmo
di dove il popolo apuano
cavatori e pastori
e le loro donne staffette
tutti armati di fame e di libertà
vi sfidava beffardo da ogni cima
questo non vi riuscì.
Ora sul mare son tornati al carico i velieri
e nelle cave i boati delle mine
chiaman lavoro e non guerra.
Ma questa pace non è oblio.
Stanno in vedetta
queste montagne decorate di medaglia d’oro
al valore partigiano
taglienti come lame
immacolato baluardo
contro ogni ritorno.   
AGAINST ANY RETURN                              

Piero Calamandrei    

Defenceless hamlets of the alps
asylum of refugees
attacked with flamethrowers
burned alive in fires in farmhouses
the children gripped to their mothers
nocturnal graves dug
by assassins on the run
to hide the massacre of slaughtered innocents
this you could do.
S. Terenzio Bergiola Zeri Vinca
Forno Mommio Traverde S. Anna S. Leonardo*
write down these names
they are your victories
but expunge these marble trenches
from where these Apuan people
quarrymen and shepherds
and their women staffette**
all armed with hunger and freedom
defied you mockingly from every crest
this you could not do.
Today on the sea sails return to the charge
and in the quarries the thunder of mines
call work and not war.
But this peace is not oblivion.
They are on the lookout
these mountains adorned in gold medals
of valour of the partisan
as cutting as blades
immaculate bulwark
against any return.    

Translation © Matilda Colarossi 2024  

Piero Calamandrei was a jurist, writer and politician. In 1925 he signed Benedetto Croce’s Manifesto degli intellettuali antifascisti. He was among the founders of the Partito d’Azione. A scholar of civil law, an anti-fascist, he was one of the very few professors and lawyers who did not apply for the National Fascist Party membership card. He was among the architects of the Constitution.

More about Piero Calamandrei here: https://paralleltexts.blog/tag/piero-calamandrei/

* In all of these small hamlets in the Carrara Alps massacres were carried out: San Terenzo Monti, between 17 and 19 August 1944, 159 civilians lost their lives during the massacre. In Bergiola Foscalina on 16 September 1944, 61 civilians were slaughtered, almost all women, young people and children. In Zeri, 3-4 August 1944, 19 people were massacred. In Vinca, two separate episodes on 24-27 August, 9 and 162 people were massacred. In Forno on 13 June 1944, 60 men were massacred. In Mommio on 4-5 May 1944, 22 people were massacred. In Sant’Anna di Stazzema on 12 August 1944, fascist and nazi units surrounded the area of Sant’Anna while a quarter stood further down the valley, above the village of Valdicastello, to block any escape route: there 560 people, including many children, were massacred in little more than three hours. In San Leonardo al Frigido, on 16 September 1944, 149 people were killed.

You can find an account of the Sant’Anna massacre here: https://paralleltexts.blog/2020/08/21/the-massacre-at-santanna-di-stazzema-the-account-of-enio-mancini-by-giulio-cavalli/

**Stafette is literally “relays”: they helped the partisans by carrying news between factions of the resistance, usually on bikes.

You can search the Italian towns and cities where massacres were perpetrated by nazi-fascist troops in the “Atlante delle stragi naziste e fasciste in Italia” [Atlas of nazi and fascist massacres in Italy] here: https://www.straginazifasciste.it/?page_id=363

This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 

Tip jar

Choose an amount

€1.00
€2.00
€5.00

If you like, you can buy me a cappuccino!

Tip

2 thoughts on “Piero Calamandrei: Contro ogni ritorno / Against any return

  1. Joseph Alan Roberts's avatar

    Dear Mati,

    It seems that poets [and their translators/ interpreters] have the art of making us realize the connectedness of things. Their reflections reflect through us.

    It was he whom the English-speaking peoples call The Bard who wrote in the eulogy, “I come to bury Caesar, not to praíse him,” and it was the trans-Atlantic poet TS Eliot who wrote, “April is the cruellest month.”

    And we have now to consider your post of April 21 and the heart-searing free verse of Piero Calamandrei in his child-innocent account of the tragic massacre at Sta. Anna.

    Saint Anne, the mother of Mary, grandmother of Jesus, is also the patron saint of Santa Ana, California, where my younger brother was born. I myself was born in [El Pueblo de Nuestra Dama, Reina de] Los Angeles in March, 1943.

    Four months later in July 1943, our late father, also named Joseph, was a young sailor, 21 years old, who was aboard a destroyer in the US Sixth Fleet that began the Allied bombardment of Sicily to prepare for the landing of the Allied armies in Europe.

    The “success” of the Sicily Campaign lead to the political and military events to follow, including the retreat of the Nazi-Fascisti into the northern territories of Italy. Their scorched-earth withdrawal practices as witnessed by the boy Piero and reported in the simple verse of the adult Calamandrei, are what in today’s realpolitick are antiseptically labelled collateral damage.

    And yet, and yet somehow, unaccountably, I feel the guilt for what was perpetrated by the evil incarnate that swept over that poor people and town.

    Is it because I did not know of the specific details of this tragic memory of Sta. Anna as rendered by your poet and parallel voicing? Partly, I think it must be. But should I have known these details already? No.

    But did I, do I need to know them? Yes.

    As that fragile innocent child who fortunately grew to adulthood taught, we are morally, physically bound to resist it happening again. And yet events beyond our reach today are repeating it, when I myself am an old man, and feel the guilt of doing nothing to resist.

    So let me add my voice to yours, dear Mati, to ask that these memories not fade, and to resist, whenever possible.

    Joseph

    Joseph Alan Roberts, Oliva, Spain

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.